| Star baker |
4 |
| Technical challenge winner |
5 |
| Technical challenge 2nd place |
3 |
| Technical challenge 3rd place |
1 |
| Hollywood handshake |
2 |
| Hollywood feint |
1 |
| Judges call bake "a triumph" |
1 |
| Judge "didn't think it would work" |
1 |
| Baker uses ingredient the judges do not like |
1 |
| Judge "loved the flavor" |
1 |
| Judge "loved the texture" |
1 |
| Judge "loved the appearance" |
1 |
| Prue's booze bonus |
2 |
| Worth the calories |
1 |
| Contesant is "flavor king/queen" |
2 |
| Contestant assists other baker(s) |
2 |
| Eliminated |
-3 |
| Bake is "underbaked" |
-1 |
| Bake is "raw" |
-2 |
| Bake has a "soggy bottom" |
-2 |
| Bake is "overbaked" |
-1 |
| Bake is "burnt" |
-2 |
| Bake is "inedible" |
-3 |
| Baker restarted a bake |
-1 |
| Baker forgot to start oven |
-1 |
| Baker stole another baker's ingredients |
-1 |
| Baker had a tantrum or brakedown |
-1 |
| Judge "didn't like the flavor" |
-1 |
| Judge "didn't like the texture" |
-1 |
| Judge "didn't like the appearance" |
-1 |
| Series winner |
6 |